Home Design & Real Estate

Your Rooms Feel Flat Because Everything in Them Is Too Perfect

A decor editor on why natural materials and craft in decor make a home feel alive, what ages well, what fails, and where to spend first.

Stacked unglazed terracotta clay plates and dishes resting on a shelf inside a pottery kiln
Photograph: KoolShooters

Natural materials and handmade pieces make a room feel lived in because they change over time. Wood darkens, linen softens and clay keeps the maker's thumbprint, so the room keeps giving you something new to notice. Last March I styled a penthouse in Tribeca where the client had spent around $40,000 on high-gloss lacquered millwork, and at 7 p.m. the living room still felt like a hotel lobby. We added one walnut bench from a woodworker in the Hudson Valley, a hand-knotted wool rug and three stoneware vessels I bought for $85 each at a Brooklyn studio sale. Two weeks later she texted me a photo of her breakfast on that bench. My position is simple: one honest, handmade object will do more for a room than a whole catalogue of flawless ones.

I've been styling homes for close to fifteen years, and the pattern hasn't changed once. Clients rarely ask for natural materials by name. They ask for warmth, or calm, or a room that doesn't feel like a showroom, and what they're describing is texture. The rooms that photograph beautifully and the rooms people actually want to sit in are often not the same rooms. You're the one who has to live there, so here's what I'd put in yours, what I'd skip and where I think your money goes furthest.

Your Hands Notice Before Your Eyes Do

Most of us spend a huge share of our lives indoors. The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency puts it at roughly 90 percent of our time. That's a lot of hours touching door handles, table edges and sofa arms. If every one of those surfaces is the same cool, sealed plastic or laminate, your body registers the sameness even when your eyes don't.

This isn't only my hunch. In 2014, Terrapin Bright Green's 14 Patterns of Biophilic Design named "material connection with nature" as its own design pattern, linked to lower stress and better mood in the research it reviewed. I read it years ago and it put words to something I'd already seen on every install. People touch a raw oak table within about thirty seconds of walking past it. Nobody strokes a laminate one.

So when I walk into a room that feels off, I start with my hands. I run them along the console, the throw, the cabinet pulls. Usually the problem shows up right there.

Photo by Mikael Dubarry

Wood, Linen, Clay and Stone Each Age Differently

Natural materials don't stay put, and that's the point. You need to know how each one moves before you buy it, because some changes are lovely and some will make you cry over a wine ring.

How the main materials behave over time

  • Solid wood darkens in sunlight. Cherry goes a deep red-brown within a year or two, while white oak goes a little golden.
  • Linen wrinkles, softens and fades with every wash. Buy slipcovers, not fixed upholstery, if wrinkles bother you.
  • Unglazed stoneware and terracotta pick up oils from your hands and develop a gentle sheen where they're handled most.
  • Marble and travertine etch from acid. Lemon juice, vinegar and tomato will all leave dull marks.

I tell clients to think of patina as a record of how the house gets used. The worn spot on a walnut stair rail tells you exactly where people's hands land. Some people love that. Others find it messy, and that's a fair reaction... but you should decide which one you are before you spend $6,000 on a dining table.

Photo by https://kaboompics.com/

The Trouble With Buying Natural Off the Shelf

The biggest misconception I run into is that "natural look" means natural. It usually doesn't. A lot of what's sold as wood is a printed film over particleboard, and plenty of "linen-look" fabric is entirely polyester. Even a real "linen blend" can be as little as 20 percent flax. Read the fibre content and the construction, not the product name. If a solid oak side table costs $129, it probably isn't solid oak.

I've made my own expensive mistakes here. In 2019 I talked a client into a honed Carrara kitchen island, sealed it once and moved on. Six months later it was covered in ghostly etch marks from her morning lemon water. She was gracious. I wasn't proud. Now I recommend quartzite or soapstone for anyone who cooks with citrus every day, and I'm upfront that marble is a choice to accept wear.

And honestly, I'm not completely sure the patina argument works for everyone. My friend Dana limewashed her own hallway after watching about four tutorials, and it came out looking less like a Tuscan villa and more like a cloudy swimming pool. She kept it for a year out of stubbornness. I told her it was "atmospheric," which was a lie, and she knew it was a lie. So yes, imperfection can be beautiful, but it can also just be bad.

Photo by Anna Tarazevich

Pay for the Maker, Not the Label

You don't need a whole room of commissioned pieces. You need two or three that clearly came from a person. Demand for that is real: the Crafts Council's 2020 Market for Craft research found that roughly three in four adults in England had bought craft, a big jump from earlier surveys. Buyers are tired of things that look identical in every apartment on the block.

Where I'd spend first

Start with what you touch most. A hand-thrown lamp base usually runs somewhere between $180 and $400 from an independent potter, and you'll switch it on every single night. A hand-forged iron drawer pull might be $30. Cushion covers in heavy Belgian linen sit around $60 to $90. These are small numbers next to a sofa, but they're the places your hands land daily.

But skip the big-name "artisan" collections from mass retailers if you can. In my experience you pay a premium for the story and get a factory finish. Go to studio sales, open-studio weekends and local maker markets instead, and ask the maker how the piece was made. If they can tell you which clay body they used or where the timber was felled, you're buying the real thing.

Tonight, walk through your living room and touch every surface you use daily: light switch, lamp, cushion, table edge. Pick the one that feels the most plastic and replace only that with something solid, woven or hand-thrown this month. You'll notice the difference every time you reach for it.

The Salon

Leave a note

Frequently asked questions

Are natural materials worth the extra cost in home decor?

For pieces you touch every day, yes. Solid wood, real linen and handmade ceramics last longer and wear in rather than wearing out. For decorative items you rarely handle, the difference matters much less.

How can I tell if furniture is really solid wood?

Look at the edges and the underside. Solid wood shows grain that wraps around the edge and continues on the back, while veneer or printed film shows a thin top layer or a repeating pattern. A price that seems too low is usually a sign too.

Is marble a bad idea for a kitchen?

It isn't bad, but it will etch from acids like lemon and vinegar, even when sealed. If you cook with citrus often and want a pristine surface, quartzite or soapstone is a safer pick. Choose marble only if you're happy to live with the marks.